Update: On 5 April 2024, the Dutch Public Prosecution Service announced that the criminal proceedings against Payvision’s former board members had been settled out of court. Rudolf Booker and Cheng Liem Li accepted fines of €180,000 and €150,000 respectively (€330,000 in total). See our report: Booker and Cheng Liem Li Fined for Massive KYC Failures.
Update: The EU Anti-Money Laundering Authority (AMLA) started its work on 1 July 2025 and is taking over the EBA’s AML/CFT mandate.
The result of the European Court of Auditors special report 13/2021
On 28 June 2021, the European Court of Auditors issued its special report 13/2021 about its investigation on the efficiency and effectiveness of the money laundering fight within the European Union with the headline EU efforts to fight money laundering in the banking sector are fragmented, and implementation is insufficient.
The European Court of Auditors detailed that during their audit, they found institutional fragmentation and poor coordination at the EU level when it came to actions to prevent ML/TF and to take action where risk was identified. In
practice, AML/CFT supervision still takes place at a national level with an insufficient EU oversight framework to ensure a level playing field.
Thousands of victims with millions of losses as a result of the poor performance
EFRI can definitely confirm these findings. But the European Court of Auditors failed to mention the “actual” results of this poor performance on cross-border coordination and poor performance in taking action against financial institutions involved in money laundering issues. The “actual” results are thousands of ripped off unsuspecting European consumers who have lost millions of their life savings to unscrupulous criminal organisations – customers of the European financial institutions.
If BaFin had acted decisively (by closing it down) against Wirecard, a fintech heavily involved in cybercrime by offering its payment services to boiler room scams around the Cartu brothers (Grey Mountain Management) as well as to the shabby Cyprus broker industry, hundreds of people who transferred their money via Wirecard’s accounts to the scammers might not have been harmed.
The same is applicable for Deutsche Handelsbank. It must have been known for years already that Deutsche Handelsbank has material issues. BaFin did not take appropriate action, such as withdrawing the banking licence, but allowed the bank to continue its services for shabby e-money companies and illegal payment services companies for many years resulting in hundreds of millions in stolen money being processed via Deutsche Handelsbank.
We think that the European supervisory authorities for the payment institutions/banks/e-money institutions must finally start doing a proper job and act decisively and swiftly to address the current material money laundering issues.
The rising cybercrime threat
The world faces several threats, one of the newest threats we are facing, and perhaps the fastest growing, is cybercrime. Cybercriminals, hackers and foreign adversaries are becoming more sophisticated and capable every day in their ability to use the Internet for nefarious purposes.
We are dependent on the Internet – we use it for everything. We communicate online, bank and shop online, and store much of our personal information there. The economies globally count on having ready access to the Internet and its many capabilities in our daily routines. The Internet opens new worlds to users and criminals.
The cost of cybercrime – already in the billions of dollars and euros – rises each year.
Why do we want the EBA to act as soon as possible?
Within Europe, Europol estimates that the value of suspicious transactions is equivalent to about 1.3 % of EU GDP. Across the globe, the figure is estimated to be close to 3 % of world GDP. Recent data shows that over 75 % of suspicious transactions reported in the EU came from credit institutions in more than half of the Member States[1].
Financial institutions must act as gatekeepers to the financial system and therefore have an immensely important role in the collective fight against the rising cyber threat.
The use of the incumbent financial system is essential to the intake of the victims’ money, to launder it and, finally, to transfer the money to bank accounts under the direct control of the scammers.
Without their illicit proceeds used to fund criminal activities, the lifeblood of the scammers’ operations is disrupted.
Financial institutions failing to do proper customer due diligence and to monitor transactions undermine the trust of citizens in financial institutions, negatively affect market integrity and threaten the stability of the financial system.
The EBA recently got an enhanced mandate to lead, to coordinate and to monitor AML/CFT efforts in the European Union.
We understand that the EBA is supposed to coordinate supervisory actions at Union level to ensure that financial institutions apply effective and robust AML/CFT controls wherever they operate in the single market[2].
The EBA[3] has the power to investigate a potential breach of Union law (BUL) relating to AML/CFT legislation at Member State level. This could involve inadequate supervision allowing large volumes of ML/TF to take place in a bank.
The EBA seems to be the appropriate authority, considering that cybercrime attacks such as boiler room frauds do not know country borders and damage and hurt victims all over Europe.
It is evident that national interests can prevent the start of a criminal investigation for money laundering, notwithstanding clear evidence.
The role of a Dutch payment institution (licensed and supervised with the DNB) in a transnational criminal organisation
As early as 5 June 2019, EFRI sent numerous documents about the cooperation of PAYVISION with the criminal organisations of Gal BARAK and Uwe LENHOFF to the relevant supervisory authority in the Netherlands (De Nederlandsche Bank/DNB) as well as to ING for appropriate actions against the former board of management.
Up to now, we have not learned about Dutch money laundering investigations being launched at the request of DNB against the former board of management of PAYVISION or PAYVISION itself.
Although ING supports the idea of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) principles in so many press releases and strongly stresses the importance of integrity, they evidently do not care about harmed European consumers.
Not investigating PAYVISION and the former board of management publicly for proven failure to comply with Know Your Customer rules and transaction monitoring for so many years and their evidenced involvement with criminal organisations, especially after the close personal relationship between the board of management and the beneficial owners of the criminal organisations (specifically Uwe LENHOFF) got evident, does not seem to be appropriate with all the cybercrime threats ahead of us and with the specific drug situation in the Netherlands.
On behalf of 988 European victims of cybercrime attacks, we ask the EU authorities to finally start fighting money laundering seriously and to hold the management of financial industry players responsible for supporting cybercriminal activities.
The full letter can be read here.
[1] Press Release on the Report of the European Court of Auditors on The EU needs a stronger and more coherent oversight framework for combating money laundering
[2] https://www.eca.europa.eu/Lists/ECADocuments/SR21_13/SR_AML_EN.pdf
[3] Regulation (EU) No 1093/2010 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 24 November 2010 establishing a European Supervisory Authority (European Banking Authority), amending Decision No 716/2009/EC and repealing Commission Decision 2009/78/EC, OJ L 331, 15.12.2010, pp. 12-47, as lastly amended by Regulation (EU) 2019/2175 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 December 2019.








